Comparative study of using rigid and flexible pavement for roads. Impact of design features on pavement response fhwa us. This has led for a need of rapid construction of roads and transportation infrastructure. In rigid pavements, the stresses are not transferred from grain to grain to the lower layers as in the ease of flexible pavement layers. Learn the basic differences between flexible and rigid pavements. This paper presents the results of pavement plateau dimensioning, designed for traffic of heavy vehicles dump trucks exclusively with a. In contrast to the aashto 1993 guide, in which the pavement design is based on serviceability loss, the pavement design thickness predicted using the mepdg is established based on the userdefined pavement performance criteria at the desired reliability level. Engineers must always determine the requirements of the. In flexible pavements load distribution is primarily based on layered. Only distress data collected using manual techniques were used in this study. Besides the obvious differences of low weight and flexibility what are the high level technical differences between flexible and rigid solar panels. Key words flexible pavement, rigid pavement, lifecycle cost analysis, alternate pavement design.
The study permits the comparison of flexible and rigid pavement concepts to determine which has been the most economical. Request pdf comparison of fatigue criteria for flexible and semirigid pavements abstract the paper presents comparison of fatigue criteria which are used in mechanistic methods of pavement. Flexible pavements use bitumen as binder while rigid use concrete. Design flexible and rigid pavements 9design principlespavement components and their roledesign practice for flexible and rigid pavements, ircmethods only. Ufc 325001 pavement design for roads and parking areas. A rigid pavement used to strengthen an existing flexible. Before we differentiate between flexible pavements and rigid pavements, it is better to first know about them. Types of pavements flexible pavement rigid pavement. The purpose of this study is to conduct comparison in total present cost between flexible pavement and jointed plain concrete pavement to locate a feasible long.
Properties flexible rigid design principle empirical method based on load distribution characteristics of the components designed and analyzed by using the elastic theory material granular material made of cement concrete. Before we differentiate between flexible pavements and rigid pavements, it is better to first. A 2 ft gap is left between the end of the pavement and the beginning of the approach slab. Flexible, usually asphalt, is laid with no reinforcement or with a specialized fabric reinforcement that permits limited flow or re positioning of the roadbed under ground changes. A pavement constructed on an existing base pavement to increase loadcarrying capacity or correct a surface defect. Flexible pavement load transfer is from grain to grain to the lower layers the design greatly depends upon the subgrade strength irc 372012 code is used for designing flexible paveme. A terminal joint figure 79 is placed where a pavement ends at a bridge or similar structure.
In highway engineering, what is the difference between a. This document is a technical summary of the federal highway administration report, impact of design features on pavement response and performance in rehabilitated flexible and rigid pavements fhwahrt10066. Introduction to rigid pavement design ced engineering. This paper compares for india the properties and costs of a cement concrete rigid pavement with those of a flexible pavement, composed of granular material, waterbound macadam, and a bituminous course.
This report documents the research conducted for the texas department of. In flexible pavements, underlying layers play very important role. A comparative study on rigid and flexible pavem ent. The rigid pavements is tested with the plate theory.
Flexible pavement designs when allowed as alternate bids performed in cooperation with the texas department of transportation and the federal highway administration march 2009 published. The main difference between the flexible and rigid pavements is based on the manner in which the loads are distributed to the subgrade. Uniform contact pressure variable deflection profile. Any comparison between faarfield and the design curve methodology from previous. In this project we want to compare between the flexible and rigid pavement design methods. Difference between flexible pavement and rigid pavement. Flexible pavements are those pavements which reflect the deformation of subgrade and the subsequent layers to the surface. Comparison of fuel consumption on rigid versus flexible pavements along i95 in florida michael bienvenu, phd, pe professor of practice in concrete pavement sustainability department of civil and environmental engineering florida international university 10555 west flagler street miami, fl 33174 phone. Comparison between flexible pavement and rigid pavement in. Rigid pavement is designed and analyzed by using the elastic theory. Jpcp controls cracks by dividing the pavement up into individual slabs separated by contraction joints. Comparision between rigid and flexible pavement essay. Comparison based on carbon foot print another comparison between flexible and rigid pavements could be in terms of carbon foot prints spent during construction.
The unified facilities criteria ufc system is prescribed by milstd 3007 and provides planning, design, construction, sustainment, restoration, and modernization criteria, and applies. Difference between flexible and rigid pavement types of. What are the technical differences between flexible and rigid. The properties most relevant to an economic comparison are the material composition and roughness of the pavement. Comparison of fuel consumption on rigid versus flexible pavements along i95 in florida michael bienvenu, phd, pe professor of practice in concrete pavement sustainability. Comparative studies of flexible and rigid pavement design. Load transfer is from grain to grain to the lower layers. The data are entered into an excel spreadsheet database format for analysis at a later. What is the difference between flexible and rigid pavements. Oct 02, 2017 the essential difference between flexible and rigid pavement are as follows.
A thin layer of flexible pavement over rigid pavement is an ideal pavement with most. May 07, 2018 the lifespan of the design of flexible pavement is 15 years whereas, in case of rigid pavement, the time period of lifespan is 30 years double to flexible pavement. The semirigid pavement with higher performances for roads. Rigid vs flexible pavement civil engineering pavement. Jointed plain concrete pavement is the most common type of rigid pavement. However, the terms rigid and flexible provide a good description of how the pavements react to loads and the environment. Irc 372012 code is used for designing flexible pavement the stability of flexible pavement depends upon aggregate interlock, particle friction and cohesion.
It is not intended as definitive treatise, and it does not encompass the design of rigid pavements. Professor of practice in concrete pavement sustainability. The stresses are not transferred from grain to grain to the lower layers as in the case of flexible pavement layers. Roads are one of the countrys basic infrastructural facilities where high amount of budget allocated during every fiscal year planning. What is the typical lux vs current curves for such solar panels. Flexible pavements are less expensive in regards to their initial cost and maintenance. It is generally central portion of the total land width and the bituminous concrete is placed or paved as to provide good service for the users.
A comparative study on rigid and flexible pavement. Comparative cost analysis between asphalt pavement and. Critical condition of stress in the rigid pavement is the maximum flexural stress occurring in the slab due to wheel load and the temperature changes. Difference between flexible and rigid pavements civil. Types of pavements flexible pavements and rigid pavements. Flexible pavement a rigid pavement has a very high stiffness and distributes loads over a relatively wide area of subgrade a major portion of the structural capacity is contributed by the slab itself. In simple terms, a flexible pavement can be defined as a pavement layer comprising of a mixture of aggregates and bitumen, heated and mixed properly and then laid and compacted on a bed of granular layer. The difference between a structure that is rigid and one that is flexible is that the. Base material shall be manufactured from hard, durable stone or recycled building materials free of clay lumps, organic matter and other deleterious substances. Seeley 1993 classified pavement into two categories, flexible pavement and rigid pavement. What is the difference between flexible and rigid pavement. Index performance comparison of pavement rehabilitation.
Rigid pavement rigid pavements are those which possess note worthy flexural strength or flexural rigidity. Today the majority of us state agencies build jointed plain pavements. The semi rigid pavement with higher performances for roads and parking aprons dong qing wu, daud. The ends of the pavement and the approach slab are placed on a sleeper slab that has been previously poured. Dec, 2016 critical condition of stress in the rigid pavement is the maximum flexural stress occurring in the slab due to wheel load and the temperature changes. Comparison between flexible pavement and rigid pavement in highway construction. Forethought should be given to the design and placement of the pavement joints so that the end result is a properly functioning pavement system. The pavement design is also one major factor, with flexible pavements reliant on subgrade strength and rigid pavement dependent on the flexural strength of concrete. A comparative study between the alberta transportation. During a recent search i discovered the existence of flexible solar panels. The project titled evaluation of flexible and rigid pavements construction in bangladesh, submitted by mohammad arifuzzaman bhuyan, roll no. Pdf the last century has seen an intensive process of urbanization in rural as. Mechanistic empirical pavement design guide and compared with the field. This paper presents the results of pavement plateau dimensioning, designed for traffic of heavy vehicles dump trucks exclusively with a weight of 2,350 kn, ie.
Rigid pavements are those which contain great amount of flexural strength or flexural rigidity. Pavement lifecycle cost studies using actual cost data. The sections provided a total of fourteen miles of data for each. Flexible pavement has very low modulus of elasticity less strength. Flexible pavement differ from rigid pavement in terms of load distribution. Pavement lifecycle cost studies using actual cost data a synthesis executive summary this synthesis presents the results of studies of interstate highways in three states which show the comparison of costs between hot mix asphalt hma pavements and portland cement concrete pcc pavements. Apr 27, 2015 updated on feb 2017 carriageway a carriage way is defined as the width or portion of road which is used by the vehicular traffic for their movement. Advantage and disadvantage of flexible and rigid pavement. Paquette and wright 1987 categorised pavements into rigid, flexible and composite. Existing pavement to be overlaid with rigid pavement is composed of an all bituminous or flexible overlay on a rigid base pavement. Flexible pavement s load carrying capacity is dependent on the layers. To compare the lifecycle of cost of concrete grade 35 pavement and.
The demand for better roads and services required researchers. Connection between rigid pavement and flexible pavement. For simplicity and not going much deeper in the differentiation the following points can be listed as difference between them. The rigid pavements posses noteworthy flexural strength or flexural rigidity. It is only shows details of joints for rigid pavement together, not connection between rigid pavement and flexible. Road construction projects have been implemented all over ethiopia as part of the national development plan. The technician is responsible for inspecting all joints to avoid any of the problems associated with joint failure. Flexible plate the deflection under a rigid plate is 79% of that under a flexible plate.
Following are the different components of road structure. Difference between flexible pavements and rigid pavements. It is not intended as definitive treatise, and it does not encompass the design of flexible pavements. Modulus of elasticity of rigid pavement is very high, because of high strength concrete and more load bearing capacity of the pavement itself. The design greatly depends upon the subgrade strength. Comparision between rigid and flexible pavement essay 7522. Difference between flexible and rigid pavements is based on the manner in which the loads are distributed to the subgrade.
Compared to flexible pavement, rigid pavements are placed either directly on. What are the difference between tender and contract documents. Surface course or wearing course all these components belong to a typical flexible pavement, whereas rigid pavement usually consists of subgrade, subbase and a concrete slab. The last century has seen an intensive process of urbanization in rural as well as metro cities. The sleeper slab is finished smooth and allowed to. To compare the initial cost of concrete grade 35 pavement and asphalt pavement in roads. Pdf a comparative study on rigid and flexible pavement. Rigid pavements as the name shows are like rigid slabs placed on earth which takes load by itself though its strength and rigidity. Comparison between flexible and rigid pavement comparison of rigid and flexible pavement. The approximate slab thickness obtained from the first run is used in calculating the damage during different seasons of the year. The pavements transition between flexible and rigid between mm 196 and mm 197, in both directions. Engineering comparison between flexible and rigid pavement submitted by. This is an introduction to flexible pavement design for engineers. Director, csircentral road research institute, delhi two types of pavements are laid in india rigid pavement and flexible pavement.
This is an introduction to rigid pavement design for engineers. Jpcp does not use any reinforcing steel but uses dowel bars and tie bars. Rigid pavements can contain reinforcing steel, that is normally applied to deal with thermal stresses to decrease or eliminate joints and retain tight crack widths. In addition to these, composite pavements are also available. Layers system aashto design method asphalt institute ai portland cement association pca studding international flexible and rigid pavement design methods. Types of pavements there are two types of pavements based on design considerations i.
What is the difference between rigid pavement and flexible. These classical definitions, in some cases, are an oversimplification. April 2004 has been accepted as satisfactory in partial fulfilment of requirement of the requirement for the. Oct 04, 2017 flexible and rigid difference with complete details leacture. The essential difference between flexible and rigid pavement are as follows. Historically, pavements have been divided into two broad categories, rigid and flexible.
This report documents a study conducted to evaluate pavement. Deformation in the sub grade is transferred to upper layers. Where reference documents are quoted in this set of guidance notes. Actual costs being the dollars spent, to date, to construct and maintain the pavements. Compared to flexible pavement, rigid pavements are placed either. Standard specification for urban infrastructure works 47 edition 1, revision 02 oct 2010. Rigid pavements are made up of portland cement concreteeither plain, reinforced or prestressed concrete. Cost and benefit analysis of rigid and flexible pavement. Engineers are cautioned that much of pavement design is governed by codes, specifications and practices of public agencies.
553 634 525 1050 537 669 1574 837 322 845 238 498 994 1620 783 447 435 451 360 793 589 584 350 189 728 1422 370 1422 856 952 171 513 916